Contact Us

Turnkey vs Consigned Materials PCBA

Turnkey vs Consigned Materials PCBA

The question is never which model is better. It is which model fits this build. Turnkey means the assembly house buys the material and delivers finished boards at one price. Consigned means the customer buys the material, ships it in, and pays for the work of placing it. The two produce different prices for the same board, and the gap is rarely the part cost alone.

Most disagreements about a PCBA quote start here. A buyer compares a turnkey price against a consigned price and sees a difference in material, then asks why the parts cost more through us than through a catalogue. The answer usually sits in the rest of the model: who holds the stock, who carries the loss on a short reel, who clears the import, who chases the shortage at eleven at night.

What changes when the material is bought for you

On a turnkey build the material is part of the delivered price. We buy to the BOM, hold the stock against the order, and the board arrives complete. The price is fixed at the quote, with the exception of parts that move weekly, and those exceptions are named on the quote rather than discovered on the invoice.

On a consigned build the material is the customer's property from the moment it leaves their dock. It sits in our store as customer material, it is counted in and counted out, and any loss during the build is a claim rather than an adjustment. The price covers labour, tooling, test and overhead only.

The difference shows up first in cash. Turnkey ties our money into your order for the length of the material lead time. Consigned ties yours, earlier, because the parts have to arrive before the line can start.

Turnkey vs consigned materials, side by side

ItemTurnkeyConsigned
Who buys the partsSUPERB PCBA, to the BOM as releasedThe customer, on their own account and terms
Price basisOne delivered price per board, material includedWork only: setup, placement, test, tooling, packing
Cash positionPaid at delivery, after the buildPaid before the build, when the parts are bought
Import and dutyHandled with the material, landed cost on the quoteCustomer's import, customer's broker, customer's risk
Shortage responseSubstitute proposed, or the schedule re-planned, with written approval on any part changeLine waits for the customer's shipment, and the wait is not ours to solve
Loss during buildAbsorbed and investigated as our material lossReconciled against the incoming count, reported as a variance
TraceabilityLot and date code recorded per reel as receivedRecorded from the customer's labels, verified on receipt
Best fitBuilds where speed and one price matter more than the last percent of material costBuilds where the customer has contracted pricing, bonded stock or export control reasons to own the parts

Where the money actually goes

A turnkey price is not the catalogue price plus a margin in most cases. It carries the cost of buying in small quantities against a large stock order, the cost of holding stock for the length of the build, the cost of a reel that is short by forty pieces, and the cost of the person who chases all of it. Those are real costs and they appear whether or not they are listed.

Consigned removes those costs from our price and moves them to the customer's side, where they are often smaller because the customer buys in volume against a yearly agreement. That is why a consigned build can be cheaper on paper for a customer with contracted pricing, and more expensive in practice for a customer buying twenty reels at catalogue rates and paying freight twice.

The middle ground most builds use

Few programs are fully one or the other. A common split is turnkey on the passives, connectors and hardware, and consigned on the two or three parts the customer has on allocation or on a bonded stock agreement. Another split is consigned on the long lead parts and turnkey on everything else, so the line is not held by a part that ships in fourteen weeks.

The split works when the BOM is marked per line, not per order. That means the BOM we receive carries a column saying who supplies each part, and the quote returns two totals rather than one. Without that column, the split is agreed in a meeting and lost in the first ECO.

A kitting arrangement sits between the two: the material is bought on the customer's behalf and delivered as a kit against the order, kitting service, with the counting and the shortage work done once. The full scope version is described under one stop BOM sourcing.

How we quote the two models

The quote is built so the two models can be compared line by line rather than as two totals. Material, bare board, tooling, placement, test, coating and packing each carry their own line. A customer who wants to move a part to consigned can see what that line was worth, and a customer who wants to move a part to turnkey can see what it will cost to add.

The checklist we use is written down under quote checklist, and it exists because most quote disputes are missing information rather than price. Builds run on seven SMT lines with 01005 placement, 3D SPI, 3D AOI and X-ray to IPC-7095, held to IPC-A-610 Class 2 and Class 3 under ISO 9001 and ISO 13485 for medical work.

Questions buyers ask

Can one order mix turnkey and consigned lines?

Yes, and it is the usual case on a mixed BOM. The BOM has to say which lines are consigned. Everything else we buy.

Who pays duty on consigned material?

The customer, on their own import. We clear nothing on their behalf unless the shipment is arranged that way in advance. This is the item most often missed when a consigned model is chosen for price reasons.

Can we specify the brands on a turnkey build?

Yes. An approved vendor list travels with the BOM and we buy to it. Where a listed part is not available, we propose an alternative and wait for written approval. Pin to pin substitution is never made on our own judgement.

What happens if a consigned part arrives short?

The count is verified on receipt, before the material goes into the store, and a short count is reported the same day with photographs of the labels. The build plan is then set against the quantity actually on hand.

Next step

Send the BOM with a column for who supplies each line, the quantity for the first build and the annual volume, and the destination country. The reply returns two totals on the same sheet, the lead time for each model, and a note on the lines where the two are close enough that schedule should decide instead of price.