Contact Us

ICT vs Flying Probe Test

ICT vs Flying Probe Test

An in circuit test fixture is usually quoted before anyone knows whether the board needs one. Two questions decide it. Does the board carry enough test access for a bed of nails, and does the volume carry the fixture? When either answer is no, flying probe runs the same electrical checks with no tooling and more time per board.

Both stations sit after reflow and after AOI, and both look for what AOI cannot see: a wrong value, a reversed part, a dry joint under a body, a net open between two points that are each soldered correctly. Which machine does the work is a cost and schedule question, not a quality question.

Why the decision arrives late in a program

A fixture can only be built from the finished artwork. Probe positions, keep out around tall parts, tooling holes and panel edges all come from the board file the customer signs off, so the fixture quote lands weeks after the assembly quote, often after first articles are already built. A flying probe program needs the same data and no hardware, so it can start on the day the first panel reaches the line.

That gap is why two similar requirements produce two plans. A fixed launch date and a board still in revision is a flying probe program by default. A released board and a two year run is an ICT program, whatever the first articles were tested on.

What each method physically needs

ICT needs hardware: a plate of spring probes on one or both sides, a press or vacuum frame, and a board that can take the force. Every node measured needs a pad, which in practice means 8 mil pads on 1 oz copper, clearance for the probe barrel, and no tall part inside the probe travel. Two sided access doubles the fixture cost and adds an alignment step on the line.

Flying probe needs none of that. Two or four heads move to a pad, contact, measure and move on. What limits it is reach around tall parts and the time each contact takes. A dense board with three thousand nodes can take minutes per side, paid on every unit rather than once.

The board decides too. A board with no test pads is not an ICT board, though a probe can still land on a lead or a via. Adding three or four pads before the artwork is released is cheaper than recovering access afterwards.

ICT vs flying probe test, side by side

ItemICTFlying probe
ToolingFixture, quoted as its own line, four to six weeks for a dense boardNone. Program built from the board file
Program timeShort once the fixture exists, because all nodes are contacted at onceLonger, since contacts are serial and the program is debugged against first articles
Time per unitTens of seconds on a mature programMinutes. The cost scales with node count and sides
Node accessOnly pads on the probe grid, 8 mil minimum, clear of tall partsPads, leads and vias, with reach limits around tall parts
Change after an ECOFixture rework or a new plateProgram edit
Volume bandSteady runs from a few hundred units upwardPrototypes, first articles, low and mixed volume
What it provesValues, opens, shorts, polarity, and the presence of the right partThe same measurements node by node, plus isolation of the fault to a net

Where each one wins

Volume decides the arithmetic. A fixture is a fixed cost, so at forty units it is a large part of the unit price and at four thousand it disappears. On a long run ICT also wins on cycle time, and cycle time is tester capacity the next program needs.

Mix decides it the other way. Six variants at two hundred units each pay for six fixtures and then store them. One flying probe program handles all six, and a change is a file rather than a plate.

Radio boards add a third point. A probe on a microstrip adds capacitance at the contact, and on a tuned filter that shifts the reading while the probe is down. Both methods answer it the same way: measure away from the tuned structures, or through a test port the drawing provides. Which nets may be probed is a question for the customer's RF engineer.

When the two run on the same lot

The common arrangement is flying probe on first articles and ICT on the run, with the first article program kept for fault isolation later. When a unit comes back from the field, the probe can measure the suspect net without a fixture and without waiting for a plate to be pulled from storage.

How SUPERB PCBA runs both

Both stations are on the same line, so the choice is made per build. Assembly runs on seven SMT lines with 01005 placement, 3D SPI after print, 3D AOI after reflow and X-ray read to IPC-7095 with voiding under five percent, held to IPC-A-610 Class 2 and Class 3 under ISO 9001, and under ISO 13485 for medical work.

Coverage is agreed before the first panel runs, and the agreement names the nets, the limits and the station. The written plan sits under test coverage plan, the stations under flying probe and ICT, and the fixture side under ICT station.

Questions buyers ask

Do we still need ICT when AOI and X-ray already run?

They find different faults. AOI checks what is visible and X-ray what is hidden inside a joint. Neither measures a value or proves that a net is continuous end to end.

Who pays for the fixture and who keeps it?

The fixture is quoted as a tooling line on the first order and stored for repeat builds, so a repeat order does not pay twice. On a build expected to stop after one run, flying probe avoids the cost.

Can a flying probe test a radio board without loading the trace?

Only where the plan allows a contact. Supply, control and low frequency nets can be probed. The radio path is tested through a port or a detector the drawing provides.

What happens when the board has no test pads at all?

We probe leads and vias where reach allows and report the nets that cannot be reached, so the gap is known before the run. Three or four pads on the next revision usually closes it.

Next step

Send the Gerber set, the BOM and the expected volume, and say whether the board is still open to a pad change. The reply returns a test plan that names the station and the nets, the fixture or program cost as its own line, and the time per unit at your volume.