A reel arrives with a dimension outside the drawing. The line is due to start in the morning. Someone writes an email asking whether the part can be used anyway, and the answer comes back after the build has already run. That email is the whole problem: a deviation waiver is a decision with a signature, a scope and an expiry date, and treating it as a conversation is how nonconforming material reaches a customer.
The waiver itself is not the failure. A waiver is a legitimate tool. The failure is a waiver that is raised after the material is on the board.
Why waivers get raised late
Incoming inspection finds the issue on receipt, but the report is written the next day, and by then the lot has been released to the line on a verbal okay. The request names the part but not the characteristic, so the customer cannot judge the risk and asks for another round of data. The disposition is written as "use as is" without a quantity or a serial range, so nobody knows how far the concession reaches. And the waiver has no expiry, so it quietly becomes the specification.
The cost of a late waiver is a shipment that has to be sorted, or a customer who discovers the deviation during their own incoming inspection and has to be told that it was known.
What the waiver request has to contain
| Field | What it has to say | Where it is captured |
|---|---|---|
| Deviation number | Unique reference, linked to the receiving lot | Receiving record |
| Part and lot | Full part number with suffix, lot, date code, quantity | Reel label, X-ray reel count |
| Characteristic | The drawing callout that is not met, with the drawing revision | Drawing and incoming inspection report |
| Measured value | Actual result against the limit, with the method and sample size | Inspection report, measurement record |
| Root cause | Supplier process cause where known, not "supplier issue" | Supplier response, corrective action reference |
| Effect on the build | Whether the deviation reaches a functional, reliability or fit parameter | Engineering assessment |
| Containment | Material quarantined, quantity held, line not released | Stock record and line clearance |
| Disposition | Use as is, rework, or return to supplier, with quantity and serial range | Approval record |
| Expiry | Date or quantity after which the waiver no longer applies | Approval record |
The expiry field is the one that changes behaviour. A waiver without an end date becomes a silent change to the specification, and the next lot is judged against the wrong limit.
Three dispositions compared
| Disposition | When it fits | Cost | What must follow |
|---|---|---|---|
| Use as is | The characteristic has margin, and the effect is measurable and bounded | Lowest, uses material on hand | Written approval, serial range, expiry, note in the build record |
| Rework or re-screen | The characteristic can be brought inside the limit by a defined operation | Middle, paid in labour and a second inspection | Rework instruction to IPC-7711 and IPC-7721, reinspection record |
| Return to supplier | The characteristic touches a qualified or safety parameter, or the quantity is large | Highest, paid in time | Replacement date, supplier corrective action, no partial release |
Defence, medical and radio frequency builds usually take the third route for anything that touches a qualified characteristic. A part that is 0.05 mm out on a connector body may be harmless. The same 0.05 mm on a radio frequency launch or a shield can change an impedance, and then the waiver has moved a measured parameter without anyone measuring it.
How SUPERB PCBA holds the line
Nonconforming material is quarantined before it is discussed. The lot is physically separated at receiving, the line is not released against it, and the decision is written before the material moves. Incoming inspection covers marking check, X-ray reel count, and decapsulation and die check where the source is unfamiliar, so the deviation is found at the door rather than at final test.
Parts are never substituted without written approval, and a substitution that is approved carries its own record: the approval, the date, the serial range it covers and the parameter that differs. Where the deviation is a supplier process issue, a corrective action is opened with the supplier and tracked to a verified root cause, rather than closed on a promise.
The build record keeps the waiver visible. Every line on the traveller carries lot and date code, so a waiver scoped to one lot can be traced to the serials that carry it, and a later field question can be answered from the record instead of from memory. Assembly runs on 7 SMT lines with 3D solder paste inspection, AOI, X-ray with void under 5 percent per IPC-7095, and functional test on customer fixtures, under ISO 9001 and ISO 13485 for medical work, so a reworked or waived unit is still tested to the same program as the rest of the batch.
The receiving discipline is described in incoming inspection plan, the supplier follow up in supplier corrective action, and the audit view in supplier quality audit.
Common questions
Who signs a deviation waiver?
The customer, for anything that reaches their drawing. The supplier can propose a disposition and give the data, but a use as is decision on a customer characteristic belongs to the customer, in writing.
Can a waiver cover more than one lot?
Only if it says so, with a quantity or a date limit. A waiver written for one lot that is applied to the next three is an uncontrolled change.
Does a waiver remove the need for corrective action?
No. The waiver decides what happens to this material. The corrective action decides whether the cause comes back, and the two records answer different questions.
Next step
Send the drawing revision, the measured values and the quantity affected, and SUPERB PCBA will reply with the disposition it recommends, the data behind it, and what would have to change on the line if the material is released. Nothing ships against a waiver until the approval is in writing.