Contact Us

Supplier Quality Audit

Supplier Quality Audit

A supplier quality audit is a test of the process, not of the folder. Most suppliers can produce a certificate, a quality manual and a corrective action form within a day. The question the audit has to answer is whether the lot that arrives next month carries the same evidence as the sample that was shown, and whether anyone notices when it does not.

That distinction matters most where the part is expensive and easy to relabel. An RF transistor, a mixed signal converter or a module bought through a secondary route can pass a visual check and still be a different die in the same package. The audit is the only place where you can see how the supplier would catch it, before it is inside your product.

Where supplier audits lose their value

The first failure is a checklist written for a different commodity. A questionnaire built for sheet metal does not test a component route, and a score of ninety two on the wrong questions is worse than no score, because it looks like evidence.

The second is auditing paperwork instead of process. If the visit never walks a live lot from receiving to kitting to the line, the auditor only learns what the supplier chose to prepare.

The third is samples selected by the supplier. Ask for the shipping log and pick the lot yourself, then follow that lot through the records. Prepared samples always pass.

The fourth is corrective action closed on paper. A ticket that says implemented without an effectiveness check is a promise, and the same defect returns quietly six months later.

The fifth is the sub-tier gap. The maker of the maker is where provenance is decided, and a supplier audit that stops at the supplier's own door leaves that unexamined.

What the audit has to test

AreaEvidence that holdsWhat a weak audit accepts
Incoming inspectionMethod, sample level and result recorded per lotA signed form with no lot number
Counterfeit avoidanceX-ray counting, marking and date code against maker data, decap where risk justifiesA written policy
TraceabilityLot number reachable from the board recordA certificate of conformance only
ESD controlANSI/ESD S20.20 program with internal audit recordsA sign on the door
Moisture sensitive partsMSL register and bake log to J-STD-033A dry cabinet in the corner
Process controlSPI, AOI and X-ray data by lotOne clean sample report
CalibrationEquipment list with due dates and statusA certificate for one machine
Corrective actionRoot cause plus an effectiveness checkA closed ticket
Change notificationWritten notice before a change shipsA verbal mention
Records retentionA lot retrievable months later on requestA promise of retention

How SUPERB PCBA answers those questions

The systems side is documented and can be read before the visit: ISO 9001, ISO 13485 for medical programs, IPC-A-610 Class 2 and Class 3, IPC-6012, 6018, 7095, 7525, 7711, 7721, 9701 and CC-830, J-STD-020 and J-STD-033, and ANSI/ESD S20.20. What an auditor should test is whether those documents describe what happens on a Tuesday afternoon.

On the component route the checks are physical. Components are counted by X-ray on receipt, markings and date codes are compared with maker data, parts that carry provenance risk are opened and checked, aged stock is verified for solderability, and a pin to pin change is made only with written approval. Verified lots carry a 730 day warranty. Counterfeit handling is described in detail on the component inspection and counterfeit detection page and on verifying original components.

On the build side the evidence is per lot: seven SMT lines with placement to 01005, 3D SPI on paste volume, 3D AOI plus DIP AOI, X-ray in 2D and CT to IPC-7095 with voiding below 5 percent, twelve zone reflow on SAC305 with nitrogen below 500 ppm, selective coating, ICT on a bed of nails and flying probe, and functional test on fixtures built internally. The flow runs seventeen steps with ten QC stations, in an SMT area at ISO 8, 22 plus or minus 3 C and 45 to 65 percent relative humidity. Acceptance is to IPC-A-610 Class 2 or Class 3 as the program requires, and the difference between the two is set out on IPC standards for assembly class 2 and class 3.

Every shipment carries the standard report, and where the program asks for it, a microsection report and an impedance test report. On RF boards a TDR coupon is built into each panel, so the impedance claim is measured rather than stated. The lot to board record is the one that answers a field return, and how that chain is kept is on component traceability for defense buyers.

On site or remote

A remote audit works if the evidence is lot based and the camera can follow a kit. Ask for a live walk from receiving to stores to kitting to reflow to test to packing, with no cuts, and choose the lot from the shipping log during the call. On site is better where the question is about handling: how a partly used reel is resealed, how a tray is stored, whether the person at the scope can explain why a joint was rejected.

Supplier quality audit questions

How long should an audit take?

One day is tight for a component and assembly scope. Two days with receiving, stores, SMT, test and the records room is realistic if you want to follow a lot end to end.

Which single record matters most?

Lot to board traceability. It is the only one that lets a field return be answered with a part, a date code and a test result instead of an apology.

Do we need to visit a component route at all?

Yes, where provenance is the service being bought. X-ray counting, date code comparison and decapsulation are process steps you can watch, and watching them is different from reading that they exist.

How often should the audit repeat?

Annually, plus a trigger: a new sub-tier, a change notice, a repeat defect, or a score that falls below your floor. An audit that is never revisited measures the day of the visit, not the supplier.

Next step

Send the checklist or the questionnaire your quality team uses, with the commodity scope. Each line comes back with the evidence reference behind it, and any line that cannot be met is marked rather than smoothed over, which is the part that makes the audit worth doing.