Contact Us

Engineering Change Order Implementation

Engineering Change Order Implementation

The change order arrives on day four of a three week build. The new revision changes one resistor, one regulator and the position of a connector. Half the boards are already assembled, the parts for the old revision are on the shelf, and the customer wants the new revision shipped. The question that decides the cost is not whether the change is good. It is where the break falls, and whether anyone can prove later which serial number sits on each side of it.

A change order is easy to write and hard to implement, because implementation is a physical act on material that already exists.

Where change orders go wrong

The first failure is the revision mismatch. The drawing is Rev C, the placement program is still Rev B, and the first board off the line looks correct because nobody compared the two documents. The second is the material: the old part is still on the feeder, so the first fifty boards carry the old revision while the paperwork says new. The third is the break itself, which is recorded as a date instead of a serial number, and a date cannot answer an audit question six months later. The fourth is the test program, which still measures the old limit, so the new part passes for the wrong reason.

The cost of getting it wrong is a mixed shipment that has to be sorted by hand, or a recall scoped to a date instead of a serial range.

What the cut in record must state

FieldWhat it has to sayWhy it matters later
Change identifierChange order number, revision from and revision to, date releasedLinks the physical build to the customer document
Affected itemsEvery part, footprint and test limit touched by the changeA single resistor change can move a test limit
Work in progress dispositionScrap, rework, or finish to the old revision, per quantityDecides whether old units can still ship
Cut in pointSerial number or lot, not a dateThe only field that survives an audit
Material consumedOld revision parts used up, quantity and lotExplains a mixed pallet without a phone call
Re-qualificationWhether a first article is repeated and which characteristics are remeasuredA new part needs its own evidence
Test program revisionProgram number and revision loaded at the stationA correct board can fail an old limit
ApprovalCustomer signature, date, and the scope it coversProtects both sides if the change is later reversed

Eight rows. The one most often missing is the fourth, because a date is easier to write than a serial range, and it is the only one that answers the question a customer actually asks.

Three routes to implement a change

RouteWhat happens to work in progressCostRisk
Scrap and restartFinished and partial units are written off, the build restarts at the new revisionHighest, paid in material and line timeLowest, one revision leaves the building
Consume and cut inBoards finish at the old revision up to an agreed serial, then switchLow, uses material already boughtTwo revisions in one shipment, needs clean marking and a serial break
Rework work in progressAssembled boards are reworked to the new revisionMiddle, paid in labour and rework riskHighest on fine pitch and radio frequency boards, where a reworked joint is a new variable

The choice follows the customer's own rule, not the supplier's convenience. Defence and medical programmes usually take the first route for anything that touches a qualified characteristic, because a mixed shipment needs a concession that costs more than the scrap. Industrial and telecom builds often take the second, with the break pinned to a serial number.

How SUPERB PCBA controls the break

A change is treated as a new configuration, not as an instruction to the line. The BOM, the placement program and the test program are revised together, and the build is held at a first article gate before any volume unit runs, with the first article compared against the released drawing on the JCX-830 station. Only after that comparison does the line release.

Material control is what keeps the old revision from leaking into the new build. Reels are counted on X-ray at receiving, date codes and lot numbers are recorded per line on the build record, and old revision parts are pulled from the line, not left on the feeder with a note. Where a rework is approved, it runs to IPC-7711 and IPC-7721 limits, and the reworked serials are recorded with the operation that touched them.

The floor runs 17 production steps over a 10 station quality line, 3D solder paste inspection, post reflow AOI, X-ray with void under 5 percent per IPC-7095, in circuit test and functional test on customer fixtures, under ISO 9001 and ISO 13485 for medical work. Moisture sensitive parts are baked at 125 degrees per J-STD-033 before reflow, which matters after a change because new parts arrive with their own floor life clock. Radio frequency parameters are measured by the customer laboratory or a partner radio frequency laboratory, so a change that moves an impedance or a gain figure is confirmed by the party that owns the measurement.

The wider launch discipline sits in NPI production launch checklist, the retest scope in PCBA test coverage strategy, and the station used at the gate in first article comparison station.

Common questions

Does every change need a new first article?

Yes, if it touches the assembly drawing, the BOM, the panel, the stencil or the reflow profile. A marking only change can usually be handled as a documented deviation instead.

Can the old revision still ship?

Only with the customer's written agreement, and only with the serial range stated. Boards finished to an old revision are not a surprise to be discovered on receipt.

What if the customer changes the revision twice in one build?

Then the build carries two breaks, each with its own cut in point and its own first article. Collapsing them into one record loses the ability to answer which units carry which revision.

Next step

Send the change order with the revision it replaces, the build number it lands on, and the disposition you want for work in progress. SUPERB PCBA will reply with the cut in point that fits the current build, the re-qualification scope, and the cost of each route before anything is scrapped or reworked.