Most boards that reach an assembly line are not one technology. They carry fine pitch parts on both sides and a handful of connectors, relays or transformers whose pins have to be soldered through the board. The mix is normal, and it is where a large part of the cost and most of the schedule surprises sit.
Mixed technology assembly is decided long before the first panel: by the clearance between the through hole pins and the nearest chip part, by the heat the connector can take, and by how many units are needed. Getting those answers early is the difference between a build that runs and a build that is re-quoted after the first article.
Where the cost sits on a mixed board
The SMT portion is priced per placement and scales with volume. The through hole portion does not scale the same way: it carries tooling, a second pass through a heat source, and often hand work that stays constant per unit however many units run. On a hundred boards it can be a third of the price; on ten thousand it is a line item nobody argues about.
Four ways to solder a through hole part
| Method | Tooling | Time per unit | Risk to nearby SMT | Fits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wave solder | Pallet or masking, one per side, plus a profile | Seconds once the pallet exists | High: the whole board sees the wave, and shadowing depends on orientation | Long runs of boards with many pins and generous clearance |
| Selective solder | Program and a nozzle, pallet often still needed | Tens of seconds, point to point | Low: heat is local, neighbouring parts stay cool | Mixed boards, connectors near chip parts, medium volume |
| Hand solder | None beyond an iron and a fixture | Minutes, operator dependent | Low if the iron is controlled, but consistency depends on the person | Prototypes, one or two pins, rework, parts that cannot take a wave |
| Pin in paste | Stencil apertures over the holes, no separate solder step | Free: it reflows with the SMT pass | None extra, the board is already in the oven | Short pin rows, parts that tolerate reflow, holes that can be filled |
Pin in paste is the cheapest option when it works, because it removes a whole pass. It fails on tall pin rows and on holes that drain paste into the barrel. Selective solder is the workhorse for mixed boards because the heat stays where it is aimed, which allows a connector to sit five millimetres from an 0402. Wave solder is fastest per unit where the board allows it, and the pallet geometry decides whether it does.
Sequence, and which side goes first
The usual order is: print and place the side with the small parts, reflow, flip, print and place the second side, reflow again with adhesive under any part too heavy to be held by surface tension alone, then insert the through hole parts and solder them, then wash, coat and test.
Two rules override the order. A through hole part that cannot survive a second reflow is inserted after the last oven pass. A heavy part on the bottom side is glued before the second reflow or it falls into the oven. Both are visible from the BOM and cheaper to find before tooling is ordered.
Clearance and shadowing rules that decide the method
Wave solder needs a path. A tall part between a pin row and the wave direction hides the pins behind it, and no amount of flux recovers a shadowed joint. Rotating the panel on the pallet ninety degrees often solves it, which is why panel orientation belongs to the tooling review.
Selective solder needs reach. The nozzle approaches at an angle, so a connector body sitting close to the pin field can block the approach even when there is room on the drawing. A tall neighbour on the approach side is the usual reason a point has to be hand soldered instead.
Pallets, masking and the tooling line
A pallet is a machined plate with pockets that expose only the areas to be soldered. It protects the SMT side, holds the board flat and sets the depth of the wave. It is also a real cost: one per side, machined from the panel drawing, and worth storing because a repeat order should not pay twice.
Masking tape and plugs are the cheap alternative for a handful of units and the wrong answer for a run: the labour per unit never falls. When a program is expected to repeat, the pallet is the cheaper line on the quote even though it is the larger number at the start.
Inspection and the fill question
Through hole joints are inspected in three stages. Visual after solder checks the fillet and the wetting angle around the pin. X-ray checks the barrel, which is the part nobody can see, and it is the only way to measure vertical fill.
The fill requirement is agreed before the first panel, because it changes with the class of the product and the pin length. IPC-A-610 sets a minimum vertical fill that rises with class. Writing the figure into the build plan avoids the argument where a customer measures a barrel that was never claimed to be full.
Small lots and changeover
A mixed board at two hundred units is not a scaled down version of the same board at twenty thousand. At low volume the pallet may never pay back and hand solder on a few pins is cheaper than a selective program, which is why the high mix low volume approach prices setup separately from the unit.
How SUPERB PCBA runs a mixed build
Assembly runs on seven SMT lines with 01005 placement, 3D SPI after print, 3D AOI after reflow and X-ray read to IPC-7095 with voiding under five percent, held to IPC-A-610 Class 2 and Class 3 under ISO 9001, and under ISO 13485 for medical work.
For through hole content the line carries a wave solder station and selective soldering, so the method is chosen per build. Pallets are quoted as their own tooling line and stored for repeat orders. Where a board needs both, the sequence is agreed with the customer before the first panel, including which parts are inserted after the last oven pass.
Questions buyers ask
Can the through hole parts be inserted before reflow to save a pass?
Only where pin in paste works: short pin rows, holes that hold the paste, and parts rated for the reflow excursion. Tall connectors and electrolytic parts are inserted afterwards.
Who pays for the pallet?
The pallet is quoted as tooling on the first order and stored for the program. A repeat order does not pay for it again, and the pallet is returned or held at your instruction if the program ends.
Next step
Send the Gerber set, the BOM with the through hole parts marked, the assembly drawing and the quantity for the first build. The reply returns the soldering method proposed for each through hole group, the tooling cost as its own line, the number of passes, and the point in the sequence where any part has to be inserted by hand.