Contact Us

Vendor Consolidation

Vendor Consolidation

Vendor consolidation is usually started for a commercial reason and then judged on a supply reason. Fewer vendors mean fewer invoices, fewer quality files and fewer dates to line up, and they also mean that one failure reaches more of the BOM. The decision is not how many vendors to keep, it is which lines can be carried by one source and which cannot.

A program that consolidates by spend alone tends to keep the vendor with the largest order value and drop the one that held the awkward lines. The awkward lines are the reason the second vendor existed.

Where vendor consolidation goes wrong

Consolidation by spend is the first mistake. Spend is concentrated on the high value semiconductors, while the lines that actually stop a build are the connectors, the custom magnetics and the parts on allocation. A vendor list cut by value removes coverage where it is thinnest.

Single source on critical lines is the second. One source per line is efficient until that source has a quality hold, a price move or a capacity allocation, and then the line has no second route at the moment it needs one. The lines that need a second route are the ones with a long lead time, a single qualified maker or a qualification cost that makes a fast change impossible.

Quality files split across vendors are the third. Each vendor keeps its own inspection record and its own lot numbering, so a field return is traced through as many systems as there were vendors on the BOM. Consolidation only pays if the record consolidates with it.

Lead time visibility is the fourth. Ten vendors give ten answers in ten formats, and the planner rebuilds the picture every week. One source gives one picture, provided that source reports the date per line rather than one date for the order.

Exit is the fifth. A vendor that is dropped for price is hard to bring back after a qualification lapse, and a vendor that is kept only for one awkward line is usually the one that stops answering. The exit plan belongs in the consolidation decision, not after it.

What decides a vendor consolidation

DecisionWhat it controlsWhat a weak consolidation looks like
Lines each vendor carriesHow much of the BOM one failure can reachVendor list cut by spend only
Critical lines kept dualWhether a quality hold stops the buildOne source on every line
Approved alternative per lineThe speed of a substitutionFirst alternative searched during a shortage
Quality file ownershipWhether a field return can be tracedRecords split across vendors
Lot numbering schemeWhether records can be joined at allEach vendor numbers its own way
Lead time reported per lineThe accuracy of the build planOne date quoted for the whole order
Inspection level per commodityWhether incoming risk is matched to the partSame check for every commodity
Substitution authorityWhether a change needs written approvalSwaps made at the vendor's discretion
Payment and currency termsThe working capital effect of fewer invoicesTerms renegotiated per order
Exit and re-entry planWhether a dropped route can come backNo route back after a quality lapse

How SUPERB PCBA supports vendor consolidation

Send the current vendor list with the lines each one carries, the annual volume and the lines that have stopped a build in the last two years. The reply maps the BOM onto a consolidated structure, marks the lines that must stay dual, and states the alternative available for each critical line before it is needed.

The commercial arithmetic sits in how to reduce component cost, and the total cost view, including scrap, rework, inspection and expediting, is set out in total cost of ownership in component sourcing. The operating model for a consolidated list, with the dates, records and approvals it has to produce, is covered in OEM procurement.

Consolidation does not remove the second route, it makes it visible. Each critical line is quoted with its primary route, its approved alternative and the check that approved the alternative, so a quality hold on one route becomes a switch rather than a search.

The record that has to survive the consolidation

When several vendor files become one, the audit trail has to stay answerable: the purchase order, the lot number of every critical part, the certificate of conformance, the incoming inspection result and the build test data of the lot the part went into. Merging vendors without merging those records loses the trace, which is the part of the consolidation that is hard to rebuild later.

SUPERB Assembly builds and tests under IPC-A-610 Class 2 and Class 3 and ISO 9001, with placement down to 01005, boards supported from 500 MHz to 77 GHz, impedance held to plus or minus 5 percent and to plus or minus 2 percent where the circuit needs it, and up to 68 layers. First article inspection, 3D SPI, 3D AOI, X-ray in 2D and CT mode with voiding below 5 percent, and functional test all report against the same lot number. Parts are checked before they enter that record: reels counted by X-ray, markings and date codes compared with maker data, decapsulation where the risk justifies it, and a solderability check on aged stock. Verified lots carry a 730 day warranty, and SUPERB Tech keeps the mapping so a field return is traced to the parts, not to a vendor list.

Vendor consolidation questions

How many vendors should a BOM have?

As many as the critical lines need, and no more. The useful figure is not the total, it is the number of lines that would stop a build if one vendor failed, and that number should be as close to zero as the qualification budget allows.

Which lines should stay dual sourced?

Lines with a long lead time, a single qualified maker, a qualification cost that blocks a fast change, or a history of allocation. A commodity passive with three equivalent makers rarely needs a second vendor; a custom connector often does.

Does consolidation raise the price?

It can raise the unit price of an awkward line and still lower the cost per unit built, because it removes expediting, scrap from partial kits and the labour of managing several dates. The comparison has to be made at that level.

What happens to the quality records of a dropped vendor?

They have to be transferred or retained before the relationship ends. A record that stays with a vendor that no longer supplies you is a record you cannot produce in an audit.

Next step

Send the vendor list with the lines each one carries, the annual volume and the lines that have caused a stop in the last two years. You get a consolidated structure with the dual sourced lines marked, the alternative named for each critical line, and the record handover needed to keep the audit trail intact.