Contact Us

PPAP Submission Checklist

PPAP Submission Checklist

A customer approves the sample, then asks for the PPAP package before the first production order is released. The boards are ready and the parts are on the shelf, but the folder that decides whether the line starts has no owner yet. This is where most first builds lose a week, and it is rarely the fault of the product.

PPAP, the production part approval process, is a document set that shows a process can repeat what the sample did. Every element in it is evidence from a real run, on the real line, with the real tooling, using parts from the real supply chain.

Why a submission is rejected after the sample passed

Most rejections come from three habits. The package is assembled from the sample build rather than from a production run, so the process capability numbers describe a bench, not a line. The documents are collected after the run, so the dates and the lot numbers do not line up. And the measurement system is assumed to be fine, because nobody wrote down how the gauge was checked.

The reviewer is not looking for perfect numbers. The reviewer is looking for a package where every claim can be traced to a record, a lot and a date.

The checklist, element by element

The table below covers the elements a customer normally asks for on an electronics build. The right hand column is the reason each one is requested, which is what decides how much evidence is enough.

ElementWhat the reviewer is checkingCommon gap
Drawing and change recordRevision level matches the parts that were builtPackage shows an older revision than the build
Engineering change documentsEvery change since the last approval is listedChanges agreed by email are missing
Customer engineering approvalThe customer has accepted the sample formallySample approval was verbal
Process flow diagramSteps match what the line actually doesFlow shows steps that were skipped on the run
Process failure mode analysisHigh risk steps have controlsControls listed but not linked to a check
Control planEvery control has a frequency, sample size and reaction planNo reaction plan when a check fails
Measurement system analysisGauges and testers are capable for the toleranceOnly one gauge studied, others assumed
Dimensional resultsActual readings against the drawing, not a pass markResults copied from the sample report
Material and performance test resultsTests run on parts from the production lotReports from an earlier lot attached
Initial process studyCapability index on the characteristics that matterStudy run on a stable bench, not the line
Qualified laboratory documentationThe lab that ran the test is acceptable to the customerScope of the lab not shown
Appearance approval reportCosmetic limits agreed where appearance mattersNo agreed limit, so every unit is a debate
Sample production partsSamples come from the production runSamples are hand built
Master sampleA signed reference unit is retainedNo retained unit, so disputes cannot be settled
Checking aidsFixtures and gauges are listed with their statusCustomer fixture used but not recorded
Customer specific requirementsThe customer own additions are answeredAdditions ignored because they sit in an appendix
Part submission warrantOne signed summary that ties the package togetherWarrant signed before the last element arrived

What the run has to deliver before the package exists

A PPAP package cannot be assembled from a pilot of ten boards. The run has to be long enough for the process to settle, and the usual expectation is a short consecutive production run with parts from the same lots recorded on the build traveller.

RequirementWhat SUPERB PCBA records on the build
Traceable materialLot and date code per line, X-ray reel count on incoming, decapsulation and die check where a part is suspect
Controlled process17 step production flow, 10 station quality line, 3D solder paste inspection, post reflow AOI, DIP AOI, X-ray with void under 5 percent per IPC-7095
Qualified people and areaIPC-A-610 Class 2 or Class 3 operators, ANSI/ESD S20.20 handling, SMT area held at ISO 8 with 22 plus or minus 3 degrees and 45 to 65 percent humidity
Measured outputFirst article comparison against the customer data on a JCX-830, in circuit test and functional test on customer fixtures where supplied
Retained recordsBuild documents, test logs and material records held for the agreed retention period, with a 730 day warranty from delivery

Radio frequency characteristics are the one area where the package has to name the laboratory. Production test at SUPERB covers direct current checks, functional test and customer fixtures. Gain, noise figure and return loss are measured by the customer laboratory or by a partner radio frequency laboratory, and the report is issued by that laboratory. Writing this into the package at the start is faster than being asked about it during the review.

How SUPERB PCBA prepares the package

The package is scoped before the run, not after it. The customer specific requirements are read first, the control plan is written for the steps the line actually performs, and the measurement studies are assigned to the gauges that will be used on the build. Where a characteristic cannot be measured on site, the package names the laboratory that will measure it.

Builds run under ISO 9001, and under ISO 13485 for medical work. Assembly sits on 7 SMT lines with placement down to 01005, reflow in twelve zone ovens under nitrogen below 500 ppm, and moisture sensitive parts baked at 125 degrees per J-STD-033 before reflow. The records behind each step are the same records the package quotes, so the review and the audit see one set of numbers. The related work is set out in NPI production launch checklist and sourcing audit trail, with incoming checks covered in incoming inspection plan.

Common questions

Can a PPAP package be issued for a build we have not run before?

Not honestly. The elements that carry weight, dimensional results, material test results and the initial process study, all come from a production run. What can be prepared in advance is the control plan, the process flow and the measurement studies, and doing that shortens the package by days once the run finishes.

How long does the package take to assemble?

With the run complete and the drawings agreed, a package for a board of a few hundred placements is normally assembled within five working days. The variable is the customer specific requirement list, because each addition needs its own evidence.

What if a part is substituted during the approval window?

Then the change goes through the customer before the part is placed. A pin to pin equivalent is proposed with the parameters that differ, and it is placed only after written approval, because an unapproved substitution invalidates the whole submission.

Next step

Send the drawing revision, the BOM, the customer specific requirement list and the quantity of the first production run. SUPERB PCBA will reply with the elements that can be covered from our side, the ones that need the customer laboratory, and the run length that makes the package defensible.